Real truth around green hydrogen and ammonia demand today? - MP Sukumaran Nair

By: MP Sukumaran Nair

Last updated : November 17, 2026 7:13 am



Developers must recognize that prospective consumers are not simply looking for a green product


Green hydrogen and green ammonia are among the most talked-about emerging industries in the global energy transition. Governments have announced ambitious targets, international organizations have highlighted their importance, industrial conglomerates have declared investment intentions, and developers are competing to establish production facilities. Green hydrogen has even been projected as a potential game changer in the decarbonization of industries that have traditionally depended on fossil fuels. 

Most emerging sectors follow a familiar pattern. Once technologies are perfected, commercialized, and mature, investors rally to capture economic gains. Capital flows quickly toward proven returns. Green hydrogen and ammonia have not followed that script. Despite IPCC assessments highlighting the role of low-emissions hydrogen in hard-to-abate sectors, and despite Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs) and net-zero commitments for 2050 or 2070, demand signals remain uneven, often indecisive, and costly. 

There are several reasons. The technologies are evolving, the cost of production remains relatively high, infrastructure is inadequate, and potential consumers are uncertain about long-term economics. Several projects announced with considerable enthusiasm have been postponed, scaled down or abandoned. Others are waiting for financing, government support or firm purchase agreements. 

Technology is advancing but is still maturing at commercial scale. So, what is the actual state of demand today—across power, energy (including transport and shipping), industrial processing, and broader decarbonization? 

Demand is nascent and conditional 

Independent trackers and reviews show a clear picture. There is genuine interest and growing contracted volume, particularly in fertilizers (the largest existing hydrogen user), refining, and emerging maritime uses. Yet the gap between announcements and bankable reality remains wide.

Globally, thousands of projects have been announced, representing enormous potential capacity and capital expenditure. Renewable and low-carbon ammonia pipelines have reached tens to over 100 Mt by the early-to-mid 2030s in various trackers. Operational capacity is rising—especially in China, where multiple large renewable ammonia plants (hundreds of ktpa each) have started or are starting production, with RFNBO-compliant output already moving into trade. NEOM in Saudi Arabia is deep into commissioning, targeting first green ammonia around 2027 under long-term offtake. India’s National Green Hydrogen Mission has driven notable offtake: by late 2026, commitments reached roughly 555,610 tonnes per year of hydrogen-equivalent, with the majority export-oriented (Japan, Korea, Europe) and additional domestic volumes for fertilizer plants under SIGHT-type programs (hundreds of ktpa of green ammonia). H2Global auctions and bilateral deals (e.g., AM Green with Uniper and further Asian lots) are converting interest into multi-year purchase agreements.

These are real signals. Fertilizer producers, some refiners, and early maritime players are engaging because existing grey hydrogen/ammonia must eventually be displaced, and policy (carbon pricing, CBAM, incentives, RFNBO rules) is starting to bite. Shipping is advancing with ammonia-capable engines, first bunkering demonstrations, and vessel orders. Hard-to-abate sectors—steel, chemicals, long-haul transport, and high-temperature process heat—remain the strategic rationale. IPCC and related analyses consistently position low-emissions hydrogen and its derivatives as essential where direct electrification is impractical.

Yet the numbers also reveal caution. Final investment decisions remain a small fraction of announced pipelines (often under 7–10% for renewable ammonia in recent snapshots). Many projects have been delayed, frozen, or cancelled. Cost competitiveness versus grey alternatives (or even blue in some regions) is still challenged without sustained policy support or premium pricing. Consumers—whether fertilizer plants, shipping lines, steelmakers, or power generators—want to know how this “green stuff” fits their balance sheets: delivered cost, reliability of supply, contract duration, inflation protection, and certification. 

Clarity from developers is most needed 

The bottleneck is less the existence of latent demand and more the conversion of that demand into firm, financeable offtake. Developers must clarify and convince on several fronts simultaneously: 

Technology and reliability: Electrolyzer choice and performance at scale, integration with variable renewables, ammonia synthesis efficiency, and overall plant availability. Feedstock clarity (renewable electricity tie-ups, water, and—for e-methanol or e-SAF—certified biogenic CO₂) is non-negotiable. Supply-chain robustness matters; a technology failure or missing project financing can strand the offtaker. 

Economics and financing: Levelized cost of production under realistic capacity factors, project financing structures, access to sustainability-linked or concessional capital, and the role of incentives, tax credits, or contracts-for-difference. Economy of scale and long-term, preferably inflation-adjusted, affordable pricing are essential for bankability. 

Contracts and offtake: Binding, multi-year agreements with clear volume, price, and quality terms. Short or conditional MoUs do not unlock debt. Domestic policy timelines and international certification schemes (RFNBO, ISCC, etc.) shape what is bankable. 

Sector-specific pathways: Fertilizer substitution is the nearest-term volume. Maritime fuel and hydrogen-as-carrier for import markets (Europe, Japan, Korea) are next. Power and other industrial uses lag further. Consumers need sector-wise mapping of existing versus upcoming projects, not generic aspiration. 

National government policies, incentives, and timelines remain decisive. Where governments aggregate demand (India’s fertilizer tenders), provide production incentives, or create offtake mechanisms (H2Global-style), progress accelerates. Where regulatory uncertainty or infrastructure gaps persist, projects stall. 

The core truth 

Ammonia and hydrogen production is an established industrial business. There is no need to create demand where existing fertilizer and chemical consumers already exist. The challenge is to replace conventional production with low-emission alternatives at an acceptable economic cost. Similarly, refinery hydrogen consumption and selected chemical applications provide identifiable starting markets. New applications such as green steel, shipping fuels, e-SAF and power generation should be developed alongside these established markets, with due regard to their individual technological and economic maturity. 

Developers must recognize that prospective consumers are not simply looking for a green product. They are looking for an industrial input that fits into their balance sheets, meets their technical requirements and contributes to their environmental commitments without jeopardising their commercial competitiveness. They need clarity on technology, project financing, feedstock security, production economics, delivery infrastructure, reliability and long-term pricing. A project that cannot demonstrate these fundamentals is unlikely to attract serious industrial consumers, irrespective of the enthusiasm surrounding its green credentials.

Assessed on the above merits, the demand is still fragile. It depends on developers delivering credible technology choices, transparent cost trajectories, secure renewable energy and feedstock arrangements, robust financing, and sustainable long-term supply at prices that offtakers can absorb or pass through. Without that clarity, consumers remain hesitant, and the gap between net-zero ambition and actual deployment stays wide.

Governments, meanwhile, must provide stable policies, targeted incentives and predictable regulatory frameworks. Financial institutions must develop appropriate funding mechanisms, and technology providers must demonstrate commercial performance rather than merely promise future efficiencies.

The sector is not yet at the point where mature technology automatically attracts opportunistic capital. It is still in the phase where careful project structuring, policy support, and honest communication about risks and costs determine whether the announced pipeline becomes real molecules and real emissions reductions.

The truth today is therefore dual: demand is emerging and real in priority sectors, yet its conversion into durable markets hinges on developers closing the clarity gap that offtakers and financiers still face.

*Formerly Secretary to the Chief Minister, Kerala, and Chairman, Public Sector Restructuring & Audit Board, Government of Kerala.

 

green hydrogen ammonia fertilizer shipping policy e-SAF technology green chemicals environment

First Published : November 17, 2026 12:00 am