Scaling up — Bench success masks industrial engineering hurdles: Prof. (Dr.) Bhalchandra Mahadeo Bhanage, Vice Chancellor, The Maharaja Sayajirao University of Baroda

By: Prof. (Dr.) Bhalchandra Mahadeo Bhanage

Last updated : July 24, 2026 6:32 am



Industry partnerships enhance academic research by providing institutions with cutting-edge equipment, advanced technologies, and specialized expertise


Academic institutions play a vital role in the growth of any nation, as they are the breeding ground for future professionals and leaders. Collaboration between academia and industry can effectively tackle various challenges by aligning the goals of educational organizations with those of businesses in ways that benefit both parties. This partnership is crucial for enhancing research, fostering innovation, improving employability, and boosting productivity. In India, the long-term development of both the industrial and academic research sectors could greatly benefit from a structured plan aimed at ongoing progress. One effective solution to these challenges lies in industry-academia partnerships, where educational institutions and companies work together on shared projects that yield mutual advantages.

Stronger connections are needed between academic research and the manufacturing sectors that can utilize that research. Academic institutions play a vital role in shaping the workforce and leadership of any country. However, in India, these institutions have faced longstanding challenges related to funding and infrastructure, hindering their progress. A promising solution to these issues is fostering collaboration between academia and industry, where both parties work together on projects that benefit each other. Such partnerships can lead academic institutions towards self-sufficiency, improve their research capabilities, and offer students better educational experiences. 

The synergy between industry and academia is essential for driving innovation and research in chemical, pharmaceutical, and scientific fields. By leveraging the strengths of both sectors, these collaborations can accelerate the creation of new technologies, products, and services. Many chemical, pharmaceutical, and scientific organizations in India have already joined forces with academia to enhance their self-sufficiency.

Benefits of Industry-Academia Collaboration

Collaborations between industry and academia are incredibly beneficial, as they create numerous opportunities for new advancements and help educational institutions and their faculty develop fresh research perspectives. These partnerships open doors for individuals within the ecosystem and students attending these institutions. Both sides gain from these collaborative initiatives. The advantages of industry-academia partnerships include:

Financial Support: With government funding often limited, academic institutions in India frequently face financial challenges. By teaming up with industries, these institutions can secure funding for research and development projects, infrastructure upgrades, and other collaborative efforts that yield mutual benefits. Such partnerships extend beyond mere funding; they contribute to a brighter future and inspire innovative changes within the field.

Research Capabilities: Collaborating with industry can significantly boost the research capabilities of academic institutions by granting access to state-of-the-art equipment, advanced technologies, and specialized expertise. This exchange fosters the development of innovative solutions and products that are advantageous to both academia and industry. Joint projects can serve as a win-win for all parties involved as they facilitate the sharing of knowledge and technologies discovered. This collaboration propels the growth of both sectors. Research progresses more effectively when pursued collectively, as diverse groups of researchers provide essential insights that enrich the overall research landscape.

Skill Development: Academic institutions can develop relevant and industry-specific skills in their students through industry collaboration. Skill enhancement, internships, and experience need to be an essential part of the exposure among students. This can help students prepare for the job market and enhance their employability. 

Entrepreneurship: Driving forward with innovation and creativity is essential for progress. Every nation requires entrepreneurs and a population focused on growth. India has emerged as the third-largest and most advanced entrepreneurship ecosystem in the world, making it crucial to harness its advantages. This can only be achieved when brilliant minds explore new concepts and establish start-ups that can thrive in the market, positively influencing the people, society, and economy of the country. 

Additionally, collaborating with industries can inspire academic institutions to motivate students toward entrepreneurship. By working on joint projects with businesses, students can gain practical experience in developing innovative solutions and products.

Bridging the divide between academic research and the production of commercial specialty chemicals—often referred to as the "valley of death"—involves addressing significant shifts in fluid dynamics, heat transfer, and economic factors. This challenge can be met through the implementation of modular pilot-scale systems, the application of computational fluid dynamics, and the development of early partnerships between industry and academia to create scalable processes. Transitioning from a university lab to a commercial specialty chemical facility is not merely about scaling up production; it entails navigating distinct bottlenecks. 

The specialty chemicals industry, projected to approach nearly a trillion dollars in global value, is driven by innovation. From high-performance coatings to cutting-edge electronic materials and sustainable additives, the sector relies on groundbreaking molecular advancements to sustain pricing power and achieve high profit margins. 

However, a significant hurdle exists: transferring a specialty chemical formulation from an immaculate lab setting to a large-scale industrial reactor. This transition goes beyond simply increasing ingredient quantities; it demands a rigorous translation phase where many promising innovations often falter. Therefore, it's crucial to assess the Academic technology readiness levels (TRLs) during this process.

TRL 1 (Basic Principles): Scientific research begins. You observe and report basic chemical properties or novel molecular structures. 

TRL 2 (Concept Formulated): You identify practical applications. The chemical synthesis route is proposed on paper, but not yet tested. 

TRL 3 (Proof of Concept): You achieve active laboratory synthesis. The molecule is successfully created in milligram or gram scales using standard lab glassware. 

TRL 4 (Lab Validation): The process is optimized in the lab. You test basic process parameters (like yield, purity, and kinetics) using automated lab reactors or small benchtop continuous flow systems. 

The "Valley of Death" (TRL 4 to TRL 5)

The critical gap occurs when moving from TRL 4 (Academic Lab) to TRL 5 (Industrial Pilot). This step requires moving away from pristine laboratory conditions and glass apparatus into rugged engineering environments where mixing, heat dissipation, and material corrosion become major factors. To successfully bridge the gap, the chemical sector is increasingly turning to structural and technological solutions that integrate manufacturing realities much earlier in the research phase. 

Collaborating Early in the Development Process: Instead of simply passing a completed academic formulation to a chemical manufacturer, innovative companies are partnering with university researchers right from the initial R&D stages. By defining commercial requirements—like regulatory considerations, cost objectives, and safety standards—early on, academic scientists can adapt their synthesis methods and catalysts for a smoother transition to industrial production.

Utilizing Digital Twins and Simulation Technology: Current scaling processes greatly benefit from advanced computational tools, including Digital Twins and Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD). These technologies enable engineers to model how a chemical process will function at a commercial scale before committing to expensive physical pilot plants. By digitally visualizing mixing dynamics and heat transfer, researchers can identify potential failure points in bench-top formulations and enhance designs without wasting valuable raw materials.

Key Challenges in Scaling Up  

Heat and Mass Transfer Limitations: In laboratory glassware, it’s straightforward to stir and heat reactions. However, in commercial settings, the decrease in the surface-area-to-volume ratio poses significant challenges. This can lead to difficulties in cooling exothermic reactions and may create localized hotspots that compromise the quality of the product. In a large-scale 5,000-gallon industrial reactor, variations in concentration and inadequate mixing can adversely affect yields, cause molecular degradation, or generate unwanted byproducts. 

While academic settings allow for easy temperature control with standard water baths, commercial processes face a remarkable shift in volume-to-surface-area ratios, complicating the management of heat during exothermic reactions and introducing potential hazards. The transition from laboratory to industrial scale unveils engineering challenges that remain hidden at the bench scale.

Byproduct Amplification: Longer heating and cooling cycles in large vessels increase residence time. This prolonged exposure accelerates secondary reactions and generates unwanted impurities.

Catalyst Deactivation: Industrial feedstocks contain trace impurities absent in pure lab-grade reagents. These trace elements quickly poison and deactivate expensive catalysts.  

Impurity Profiles and Byproducts: Trace elements, degradation products, or material leaching from industrial reactor walls (e.g., stainless steel vs. academic glass) can act as poisons or drastically alter the final specialty chemical's performance.  

Solvent Recovery and E-factor: Academic labs use copious solvents. In a factory, recovering and recycling these solvents is a major driver of plant economics and environmental compliance.  

De-risking the Translation (The Engineering Pipeline) 

Process Development Units (PDUs)/Pilot Plants: Before building a full-scale plant, the process must pass through intermediate, scalable setups to identify hydrodynamic, mass transfer, and corrosion issues.  

Flow Chemistry & Microreactors: Utilizing continuous flow reactors allows for safer handling of hazardous intermediates and bridges the scale gap by mimicking industrial dimensions while keeping volumes low. 

Digital Twins & Multiscale Modeling: Deploying advanced process simulations allows chemical engineers to model fluid dynamics, reaction kinetics, and thermodynamic changes across scales before physical infrastructure is built. 

Economic and Regulatory Alignment 

Technoeconomic Analysis (TEA) and LCA: Academic researchers must evaluate early whether their synthetic route is commercially viable. TEA models the cost of raw materials, energy, and capital equipment, while Life Cycle Analysis (LCA) ensures the process meets increasingly stringent global sustainability and regulatory frameworks. 

Design for Manufacturability: The chemical route must be optimized for safety, utilizing non-toxic, readily available, and stable raw materials where possible. 

Structuring Industry-Academia Collaborations 

Technology Transfer Offices (TTOs): Institutions act as the bridge by managing intellectual property (IP), filing patents, and negotiating licensing agreements early in the discovery phase.  

Collaborative Consortia: Pre-competitive industry partnerships and government-backed funding initiatives (such as Knowledge Transfer Partnerships) help align academic research with direct industrial application. 

All such efforts can lead to successful industry-academia collaboration. 

Digital Twins Prof. (Dr.) Bhalchandra Mahadeo Bhanage Vice Chancellor The Maharaja Sayajirao University of Baroda industry-academia chemical petrochemical laboratory pharmaceutical scientific organizations research innovation Computational Fluid Dynamics Flow Chemistry Microreactors Solvent Recovery Technoeconomic Analysis Technology Transfer Offices

First Published : July 24, 2026 12:00 am